The Hess Files: Piecing Together Pennsylvania’s Forgotten Forest Disappearances

Watch the full timeline investigation, on-site footage, and interviews here:
👉 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VVT-JD3WJY4

🗂️ A Pattern Hidden in the Pines

For over five decades, a small section of Susquehannock State Forest in Pennsylvania has quietly gained an unsettling reputation — not for what’s found there, but for what vanishes.

This blog revisits one of the most overlooked threads in Appalachian true crime: the Raymond Hess case, its strange aftershocks, and what an amateur investigator uncovered years later.

📍 Location: Dutchman’s Hollow (Unofficial Name)

Not listed on trail maps.
Not recognized by the DCNR.
Still widely avoided by locals.

Dutchman’s Hollow is the name whispered in Clinton and Potter Counties. Hunters, hikers, and forest workers all say the same thing:

“Don’t go off trail near Drumore or Renovo. Especially if you find the rocks.”

🔎 CASE FILE: Raymond Hess (1977)

Age: 34
Occupation: Logger
Background: U.S. Air Force electronics specialist
Date Missing: March 4, 1977
Vehicle Found: Abandoned, keys removed, near a disused fire road
Date Located: March 19, 1977
Condition: Barefoot, underweight, confused, speaking in fragmented phrases
Key Phrases Reported:

“It didn’t want me yet.”
“The Hollow’s full.”
“I was watched the whole time.”

No charges. No psychiatric follow-up. Hess left Pennsylvania in 1980 and was never heard from again.

📸 FIELD NOTES: Jake Miller Encounter (1990)

In summer 1990, Lancaster County native Jake Miller, a local history hobbyist, followed clues related to the Hess case. With a friend, Tom, he explored an unmarked sector of Susquehannock Forest.

They discovered:

A stone cairn, unusually symmetrical
A buried metal tin containing the name “Hess”
A tall humanoid figure, pale and motionless, watching from the tree line

The two men fled without confrontation.

Weeks later, Miller returned with his cousin Sarah. On that trip, they found:

A burned foundation
A buried locket with no markings
A foul-smelling pit, 4 feet wide
The same figure, now closer — and still silent

They fled again. Jake lost his camera in the escape.

“Whatever’s there… it’s tied to the Hess story. And it doesn’t like visitors.”
— Jake Miller, YouTube Interview (1991 clip in video)

🧠 Theory: What Happened to Raymond Hess?

Investigators (both official and amateur) have proposed three theories:

Psychological Breakdown
Hess experienced a trauma-induced fugue state. The problem? His clothes were clean, and his feet had no major injuries, despite 14 days of exposure in rugged terrain.
Cult or Isolated Group
Whispers of a self-sufficient family or sect in the forest have been floating around since the 1800s. These people — if they exist — are feral, defensive, and very good at staying hidden.
Geological Anomaly
Certain fault lines in Appalachia produce low-frequency infrasound, known to trigger panic, hallucinations, and disorientation — possibly explaining why some people flee in terror, or go missing.

But none of these theories fully explain the unblinking figure described across multiple decades.

📍 Timeline Snapshot

Year	Event
1600s	van der Heide family settles deep in Susquehannock Forest
1806	Last known MacDuff family member disappears
1910–1980	130+ missing persons in surrounding counties
1977	Hess case
1990	Miller encounters
2024	Ongoing online reports continue to emerge

🧭 Key Warning Signs in Dutchman’s Hollow

According to repeat anecdotal accounts:

Cairns appear in triangular formations
Total silence (no insects or birds)
Unusual humidity or “air pressure drop”
Sightings of a tall, pale man just inside the treeline
Disorientation or lost sense of time

“Don’t follow the cairns. Don’t answer voices. And never go alone.”
— Trail log entry, dated July 1993

🎥 Want the Full Picture?

Our full YouTube documentary includes:

Map overlay of all 3 incident zones
Photos of the unearthed locket
Voiceover accounts from Miller and locals
Archival clippings of the Hess case
And speculation from geologists and folklorists

🎥 Watch now on YouTube

Life Style